AAA vs. Insurance Roadside Assistance: What’s the Difference?

Roadside Assistance

When your vehicle breaks down or you find yourself stranded on the road, having reliable roadside assistance can be a lifesaver. Two primary options often come to mind: AAA and insurance roadside assistance. Both offer valuable services, but knowing which one is right for you requires a closer look at their benefits, drawbacks, and coverage options.

Brief Explanation

AAA (American Automobile Association) is a well-known organization providing a wide range of services, including roadside assistance, travel planning, and discounts on various products and services. Membership levels vary, offering different benefits depending on the tier selected.

On the other hand, insurance roadside assistance is typically an add-on to your existing auto insurance policy. It provides similar services like towing, battery jump-starts, and flat tire changes but may vary significantly depending on the insurance provider and coverage level chosen.

In this article, we will compare the benefits, drawbacks, and coverage options of AAA and insurance roadside assistance. This comparison aims to help you make an informed decision tailored to your specific needs. Whether you’re looking for extensive travel perks or simply need reliable emergency support, understanding these options will guide you toward the best choice.

If you’re considering insurance roadside assistance as an option, it’s crucial to have a comprehensive auto insurance policy in place. Commercial Auto Insurance from reputable providers like Gordon Insurance can protect your business vehicles against various risks such as accidents, theft, or damage. With personalized coverage plans serving Washington DC, Maryland, and Virginia areas, they offer top-tier insurance solutions that safeguard what matters most to you.

Understanding AAA Roadside Assistance

Benefits of AAA Membership

When you consider AAA roadside assistance, you get access to many membership perks. These benefits go beyond just emergency towing and tire changes.

  • Travel Assistance: AAA provides extensive travel planning services, including maps, tour books, and discounts on hotels and car rentals. Whether you’re planning a cross-country road trip or a weekend getaway, AAA members can enjoy significant savings and convenience.
  • Insurance Discounts: Members often get discounts on auto, home, and life insurance policies. This can lead to substantial long-term savings. For example, many AAA members save hundreds of dollars every year on their insurance premiums because of these exclusive discounts.
  • Automotive Services: Besides roadside assistance, AAA offers various automotive services such as vehicle inspections, repairs, and maintenance checks. Members can use trusted service centers that provide quality work at competitive prices.

Real-Life Examples

John from Maryland shares his experience:

“During a family vacation last summer, our car broke down in a remote area. Thanks to my AAA membership, we got prompt towing service to the nearest repair shop and received a discount on the repair costs. The peace of mind was worth every penny.”

Samantha’s story highlights another aspect:

“As a frequent traveler for work, I rely heavily on AAA’s travel assistance. From booking discounted hotel rooms to accessing reliable rental cars, AAA has saved me both time and money countless times.”

Drawbacks of AAA Membership

While the benefits are substantial, there are some potential downsides to joining AAA:

  • Annual Fee Commitment: Depending on the membership level chosen (Basic, Plus, or Premier), annual fees range from $50 to $130 or more. This commitment might be higher than what some are willing to pay for roadside assistance alone.
  • Limited Coverage for Non-Personal Vehicles: Coverage is typically limited to your personal vehicles. If you frequently rent cars or use different vehicles not registered under your membership, this could pose an issue.

Comparatively, getting roadside assistance through an auto insurance provider might offer simpler solutions without extra annual fees. For an affordable option tailored specifically for Maryland residents looking for comprehensive coverage options, you might want to check out
Gordon Insurance’s personal auto insurance. Their personalized and cheap car and auto insurance quotes provide comprehensive vehicle coverage that fits within your budget.

By understanding both the advantages and limitations of AAA membership perks, you can better assess whether this option aligns with your specific needs and driving habits.

Drawbacks of AAA Membership

AAA, renowned for its roadside assistance services and extensive membership perks, does have its downsides that may impact your decision to join.

1. Annual Fee Commitment

One of the primary drawbacks of AAA membership is the annual fee. Depending on the level of membership you choose (Basic, Plus, or Premier), these fees can add up:

  • Basic Membership: Typically ranges from $50 to $70 annually.
  • Plus Membership: Generally costs between $80 to $130 per year.
  • Premier Membership: Often exceeds $150 annually.

These costs can be a significant commitment, especially if you don’t frequently require roadside assistance. The value proposition may not justify the expense for infrequent users.

2. Limited Coverage for Non-Personal Vehicles

Another consideration is AAA’s limited coverage for non-personal vehicles. If you’re driving a rental car or a company vehicle, the roadside assistance benefits might not apply. This limitation can be inconvenient if you often find yourself behind the wheel of vehicles other than your own.

3. Comparison with Insurance Roadside Assistance

When comparing AAA with roadside assistance options provided by auto insurance companies, several points stand out:

While AAA boasts an extensive network and exclusive discounts that set it apart, it’s crucial to weigh these benefits against the cost and limitations mentioned. Understanding these factors helps in making an informed choice tailored to your specific needs.

Insurance Roadside Assistance: A Comprehensive Coverage Option

Insurance roadside assistance is an attractive option for many drivers due to its integration with existing auto insurance policies. This convenience often allows you to manage all your vehicle-related needs under a single provider. One of the primary considerations when evaluating insurance roadside assistance is understanding the various levels of coverage available.

Basic Coverage

  • Towing Distance: Typically, basic plans include a limited towing distance, usually around 5-10 miles. If your vehicle needs to be towed further, additional charges may apply.
  • Battery Jump-Starts: If your car battery dies, this service will help you get back on the road without needing a tow.
  • Flat Tire Changes: Assistance with changing flat tires is often included in even the most basic plans.
  • Lockout Services: If you accidentally lock yourself out of your vehicle, help will arrive to get you back inside.

Mid-Tier Coverage

  • Extended Towing Distance: Mid-tier plans often offer increased towing distances, ranging from 20-50 miles.
  • Fuel Delivery Services: If you run out of fuel, these plans typically cover the cost of delivering enough gas to reach the nearest station.
  • Minor Mechanical Repairs: Some mid-tier options include minor repairs that can be performed roadside, reducing the need for a tow.

Premium Coverage

  • Unlimited Towing Distances: Premium plans might offer unlimited towing distances or significantly extended ranges.
  • Trip Interruption Reimbursement: This feature covers expenses like lodging and meals if your vehicle breaks down far from home.
  • Concierge Services: High-end plans may provide concierge services such as travel planning or emergency message relay.

Insurance roadside assistance often goes beyond basic services to include features that add extra value and convenience:

Trip Interruption Reimbursement

One notable feature is trip interruption reimbursement. If your vehicle breaks down while you’re away from home, this benefit can cover unexpected expenses such as:

  • Lodging Costs
  • Meals
  • Transportation Fees

This ensures that an unexpected breakdown doesn’t ruin your travel plans or strain your budget.

Concierge Services

Concierge services are another attractive feature available through some insurance providers. These can include:

  • Travel Planning Assistance
  • Emergency Message Relay
  • Hotel and Restaurant Reservations

These services aim to make your life easier during stressful situations, offering peace of mind when you’re on the road.

Mobile App Integration

Many insurance companies now offer mobile apps that allow you to request roadside assistance with just a few taps on your smartphone. These apps can:

  • Provide real-time updates on the arrival time of help
  • Offer digital proof of coverage
  • Allow you to track the status of your request

This level of convenience ensures that help is always just a click away, making it easier than ever to get back on the road quickly. While insurance roadside assistance comes with many benefits, it’s crucial to be aware of potential limitations and exclusions:

Service Caps

Some policies may have caps on certain services:

  • Limited number of service calls per year
  • Maximum dollar amount per incident

Geographical Restrictions

Coverage might be limited geographically:

  • Certain remote areas may not be serviced
  • International travel might not be covered

Vehicle Restrictions

Policies may exclude certain types of vehicles:

  • Commercial vehicles
  • Motorcycles or scooters
  • Older vehicles beyond a specific age limit

Understanding these limitations helps set realistic expectations about what your insurance roadside assistance plan can deliver.

The Benefits of Having Insurance-Backed Support

Insurance roadside assistance, offered by many auto insurance providers, has become a popular option for drivers seeking comprehensive support beyond just emergency towing. Auto insurance companies have expanded their services to include roadside assistance as an optional coverage benefit, addressing various needs that might arise on the road.

Situations Covered Under Insurance Roadside Assistance:

  • Mechanical Breakdowns: Whether your car refuses to start or experiences a sudden malfunction, insurance roadside assistance can help get you back on the road or tow your vehicle to a repair shop.
  • Flat Tires: If you encounter a flat tire, most insurance policies cover the cost of replacing it with your spare or towing your vehicle if needed.
  • Battery Jump-Starts: Dead battery? Roadside assistance can provide jump-start services to get your car running again.
  • Lockout Services: Locked out of your vehicle? Many policies include assistance for unlocking your car without causing any damage.

Benefits of Comprehensive and Collision Coverage:

Having comprehensive and collision coverage in your auto insurance policy can be particularly advantageous during roadside emergencies. These coverages typically extend beyond basic roadside assistance:

  • Coverage for Repairs After an Accident: If you’re involved in an accident, collision coverage can handle repair costs, ensuring that you aren’t left with hefty out-of-pocket expenses.
  • Protection Against Non-Collision Incidents: Comprehensive coverage can protect against theft, vandalism, and other non-collision-related damages.

Convenience Through Mobile Apps:

Many insurance companies have developed mobile apps that streamline the process of requesting roadside assistance. With just a few taps on your smartphone, you can:

  • Request Assistance Quickly: The mobile app allows you to easily submit requests for help, whether it’s for towing or mechanical issues.
  • Track Service Providers: Some apps offer real-time tracking of the service provider’s location and estimated arrival time.
  • Access Policy Information: The app provides immediate access to your policy details and coverage options, ensuring you’re always informed.

Insurance roadside assistance offers a holistic solution by combining emergency support with traditional coverage for vehicle damages. This integration ensures that you’re well-prepared for various road-related challenges.

Comparing AAA and Insurance Roadside Assistance: Making an Informed Choice

When deciding between AAA roadside assistance and insurance company-provided roadside assistance, several key factors come into play:


  • AAA Membership: Typically involves a joining fee and annual dues. Different membership levels (Basic, Plus, Premier) offer varying benefits at different price points.
  • Insurance Roadside Assistance: Often added as a rider to your existing auto insurance policy for an additional premium. This can be more cost-effective if bundled with other coverages.

Coverage Breadth

  • AAA: Offers extensive coverage including towing, battery replacement, flat tire changes, fuel delivery, and lockout services. Additional perks include travel discounts, hotel savings, and trip planning services.
  • Insurance Roadside Assistance: Coverage may vary significantly by provider. Basic plans generally cover essential services like towing and tire changes but might lack the extra travel-related perks that AAA offers.

Service Availability

  • AAA: Known for its vast network of service providers and quick response times. Availability is widespread across the United States.
  • Insurance Roadside Assistance: Service availability depends on the insurance carrier’s network. Some insurers might have limitations in rural areas or during peak times.

Personal Recommendation

Choosing between AAA and insurance roadside assistance often boils down to your driving habits and specific needs:

  • Frequent Travelers: If you frequently embark on road trips or travel long distances, AAA’s extensive network and additional travel benefits might be more advantageous.
  • Budget-Conscious Drivers: Incorporating roadside assistance into your existing auto insurance policy could save money in the long run, especially if you already have comprehensive or collision coverage.

Evaluating both options based on these factors will help you make an informed decision that best suits your requirements for reliable roadside support.

How to Access AAA and Insurance Roadside Services When You Need Them

Insurance Roadside Services

Having the right contact information readily available can make a significant difference during a roadside emergency. Here’s how to ensure you can quickly access assistance from both AAA and your insurance provider.

Saving Essential Contact Information

  • AAA Roadside Assistance Number: Store the AAA roadside assistance number, which is typically 1-800-AAA-HELP (1-800-222-4357), in your phone contacts. This allows you to request help without delay. Here are some tips on what to do when your vehicle breaks down.
  • Insurance Provider Contact Details: Save your insurance provider’s roadside assistance number in your phone as well. This number can usually be found on your insurance card or policy documents. If you’re unsure about storing important contact information on your phone, this wikiHow article offers useful guidance.

Understanding the Process for Requesting Assistance

AAA Members

  • Dial the AAA roadside assistance number.
  • Provide your membership number and location details.
  • Describe the nature of your issue (e.g., flat tire, dead battery).
  • Wait for confirmation and estimated arrival time.

Insurance Policyholders

  • Contact your insurance provider using the saved roadside assistance number.
  • Have your policy number and personal identification ready.
  • Describe the problem and provide location details.
  • Follow instructions given by the representative for further steps.

Handy Tips for Efficient Assistance

  • Keep Membership Cards/Policy Details Accessible: Always carry your AAA membership card or insurance policy card in your vehicle’s glove compartment. This ensures quick reference when you need to provide details over the phone.
  • Use Mobile Apps: Many insurance companies offer mobile apps that simplify the process of requesting roadside assistance. These apps often feature GPS tracking, which helps service providers locate you faster. If you’re interested in exploring this option, here is a list of some of the best roadside assistance apps available.

Preparing Ahead


Having backup plans can make a stressful situation more manageable:

  • Preload Emergency Contacts: Aside from AAA and insurance numbers, include contacts for local towing services and nearby friends or family who might assist in an emergency.
  • Regularly Update Information: Ensure all saved contact details are current, reflecting any changes in membership numbers or insurance policy information.

Staying prepared with these simple steps can significantly reduce stress during unexpected vehicle breakdowns, helping you get back on the road swiftly and safely.

Understanding the Costs Involved 


AAA Cost and Membership Fees

AAA membership fees are composed of several components:

  • Joining Fee: This is a one-time cost typically ranging from $10 to $25, depending on your region.
  • Annual Dues: The annual fee varies based on the membership level you choose:
  • Basic/Classic Membership: Usually costs between $50 to $70 per year. It includes essential roadside services like towing (up to 3-7 miles), battery jump-starts, flat tire changes, and fuel delivery.
  • Plus Membership: Typically ranges from $85 to $120 annually. It offers extended towing up to 100 miles, enhanced trip interruption coverage, and additional locksmith services.
  • Premier Membership: Often costs between $120 to $170 per year. It provides the highest tier of services including towing up to 200 miles, concierge services, and superior travel assistance.

Costs can fluctuate based on your location in Maryland and specific promotions or discounts available at the time of joining.

Comparing AAA with Insurance Roadside Assistance

When comparing AAA costs with insurance roadside assistance:

  • Insurance Roadside Assistance Premium: Adding this feature to your auto insurance policy generally increases your premium by approximately $5 to $20 per year. This cost is significantly lower than AAA’s annual dues but might offer more limited coverage.
  • Coverage Breadth: While insurance-based roadside assistance might include basic services like towing (usually up to a specified mileage), lockout services, and fuel delivery, it often lacks the extensive perks provided by AAA memberships—such as travel discounts or vehicle inspections.

Location-Specific Price Variations

The cost of both AAA services and insurance premium additions can vary substantially based on where you live in Maryland. Factors influencing this variation include local operating costs for service providers and regional pricing strategies.

Understanding these cost structures helps in making an informed decision between opting for a standalone AAA membership or integrating roadside assistance into your existing auto insurance policy.


Choosing between AAA and insurance roadside assistance depends on your specific needs and circumstances. Each option offers unique benefits and drawbacks:

AAA Membership

  • Extensive travel assistance
  • Exclusive discounts
  • Comprehensive automotive services

Insurance Roadside Assistance

  • Integrated support with your existing policy
  • Often more cost-effective
  • Enhanced convenience via mobile apps

Consider factors like cost, coverage breadth, and service availability to determine the most suitable option for you. Those who frequently travel or desire additional perks may find AAA beneficial, while drivers seeking simplicity and affordability might lean towards insurance-based solutions.

Prioritize emergency preparedness by ensuring you have reliable roadside support. Sign up for AAA or confirm that your insurance policy includes robust roadside assistance benefits.

For residents of Maryland, exploring both options can provide peace of mind knowing help is just a call away.


Blog Form
What type of Insurance Quote are you interested in? (Select all that apply)
What type of Insurance Quote are you interested in? (Select all that apply)